What’s Your Favorite Sweetener?
If you’ve been watching your weight for any period of time, chances are you have largely given up sugar and honey and maple syrup, except in those special desserts, in favor of artificial sweeteners. There’s the stuff in the pink packet, the blue packet, and the yellow packet. Concerns about whether or not they are safe have surfaced from time to time, but there are always those reassuring studies done by the manufacturer or some company they have hired that show they won’t kill you, at least not right away. And we do want to be thin, don’t we?
So far as I know, first there was saccharin, much sweeter than sugar, but with a slight bitter twang in the aftertaste. I grew up with it so I’m used to the taste. Anybody remember Fresca? In very large quantities it’s induces cancer in rats, but there has never been any evidence that it hurts people in normal amounts.
That was supplanted by cyclamates, which were in a pink packet. Although this one has been banned for causing bladder tumors in rats, then unbanned after further studies in rats and mice , and is now in FDA limbo. Could be a tumor promoter, i.e., it doesn’t cause tumors all by itself, but can help them develop in the presence of another carcinogen. So now the stuff in the pink packets is saccharin again.
Then there was aspartame, which the FDA does not cause brain damage, brain tumors, or endocrine disorders. Other scientists say it definitely has neurotoxic properties and it should be pulled from the market while more extensive studies are done by someone other than the manufacturer. It can break down into methanol and/or formaldehyde, which will definitely kill you, but you would have to drink a LOT of very old, badly stored soft drinks to get enough to do any harm. Still, consumer reports of symptoms like headaches or dizziness persist. The FDA says these are relatively mild and most people don’t seek medical attention and some people are just more sensitive to it. Of course it is very bad for people with phenylketonuria and is so labeled. One big disadvantage for the blue packet is that it breaks down and loses its sweetens if it’s heated, like in cooking.
The newest kid on the block is the relatively expensive star in the yellow packet, Splenda. It stays sweet when you cook with it and since it is made from sugar, then it must be OK. Right? Well, there is a dedicated group of scientists who think otherwise. There is an interesting article about artificial sweeteners, especially Splenda, on the Epoch Times website: How Sweet It Isn’t
It quotes physician and biochemist James Bowen, M.D., whose 2005 article, “The Lethal Science of Splenda, a Poisonous Chlorocarbon,” says that sucralose has been found to shrink the thymus gland and cause liver inflammation in rats and mice. The thymus gland controls the differentiation of cells that play key roles in immune responses. So I don’t think I would give anything with Splenda in it to children. Anyway it’s something to keep in mind.
So what’s a body to do? I use stevia, which is incredibly sweet, occurs naturally in a plant called “sweet leaf” and has been used for at least 1,500 years by indigenous people of Paraguay and other South American countries. There are limited studies showing it may have anti-diabetic and blood pressure lowering qualities, as well as other beneficial effects. You can buy it at health food stores. If you buy highly purified extracts, it can have a bitter, licorice-like aftertaste so try several brands until you find one that tastes right. Alternatively, you can buy the less-processed brown or green powder and you shouldn’t have much trouble with bitterness.
The other solution is to wean ourselves away from our sweet tooth. Learn to like unsweetened tea and coffee don’t drink commercial soft drinks at all. There are a number of health reasons for avoiding those. Drink mineral water, flat or naturally sparkling, by itself or with a little citrus or other actual fruit juice in it. Then enjoy your OCCASIONAL treat with natural sugars without guilt. Nobody ever got fat from one bowl of real ice cream or one piece of pie or cake or whatever a week. Enjoy! –Di
technorati tags:weight, loss, artificial, sweeteners, Splenda, stevia, saccharin, cyclamate, aspartame
No Tags














